Service Charge Is NOT Service Tax On Restaurant Bills, Finance Ministry Clarifies
After you dine in a restaurant in India, chances are there that the little percentages and amounts added to the total bill will confuse you. Although the Govt. has clarified that service tax of 14% on 40% of the overall bill (effective rate: 5.6%) will only be charged at AC restaurants/hotels, customers have realized that the total payable amount doesn’t tally with the expectations.
In most of the cases, the customers just ignore it, or they can’t locate the exact resource to clear their confusion.
Sensing the need, Finance Ministry has issued a clarification regarding service tax and service charge; and now, it makes clear that customers are being duped.
Here is the big, bold statement which customers in India should memorize by heart: Service Charge is Not Service Tax.
In fact, any service charge which we pay we retained by the restaurant, and Govt. doesn’t get any of that money. VAT and Service Tax are the only payable amount which goes to the Government coffers.
Finance Ministry clarified: “Some restaurants / hotels / eateries besides charging for the food and beverages are also charging ‘service charges’ in their bills. The proceeds of the ‘service charges’ are retained by the restaurants / hotels / eateries”
And giving a final explanation, Govt. said, “It is clarified that these ‘service charges’ collected by the restaurants/hotels/eateries are retained by the restaurants/hotels/eateries and are not ‘service tax’ imposed by the government”
But What Exactly Is Service Charge?
Service charge is nothing but an organized and enforced way to collect tips for waiters and support staff. And there are no guidelines for the same!
It can vary from 4% to 20%, depending on the restaurant/hotel’s internal policy and sometimes mood.
They assume that giving tips is mandatory, hence, they add service charge to the overall bill which means that the customer is giving tips to the staff.
As per Padma Sri, Additional Commissioner in-charge of service tax with the Central Board of Excise Customs (CBEC), “As far as the legal imposition from the government is considered, it is only service tax and not service charge which customers are supposed to pay on their total food bill.” (quoted in 2013)
Present Govt. has not indicated whether customers should pay for this service charge or not, but has certainly clarified regarding its intensions.
Decoding The Restaurant Bill
Assume you have ordered foods worth Rs 1000 in an AC restaurant (service tax can only be charged in a AC restaurant/hotel).
Assuming that the hotel has specified that they will charge 10% as service charge (or enforced tip), here is the way the bill should be ideally formed, as of now (July 15, 2015)
|Your Total Food Bill||1000|
|Service charge (assuming 10%)||100|
|Service Tax to be levied on 40% of subtotal i.e. 1100 = 440)|
|Service tax @ 14% on 440.00||61.60|
|VAT (state specific; assuming 15% of subtotal i.e. 1100)||165|
|Total amount to be paid (1000+100+61.60+165)||1326.60|
The service charge, which we have assumed 10% may sometimes go upto 30-40%, depending on the restaurants or hotel. And VAT is always state specific.
Hence, after this clarification, it is recommended that customers should always make it clear regarding the service charges to be levied by the hotel or restaurant before ordering any food. And in case it is unavoidable, then there is no requirement to give tips, as the service charge will already cover that expense.
Remember, Service Charge is not going to the Government of India, but to the Restaurant owner.