Govt Should Bring In Age-Limit For Accessing Social Media, Just Like Drinking Alcohol - Karnataka High Court


Sheetal Bhalerao

Sheetal Bhalerao

Sep 21, 2023


It would be suitable if an age limit was introduced for using social media akin to the legal age for drinking alcohol, said the High Court of Karnataka on Tuesday.

Govt Should Bring In Age-Limit For Accessing Social Media, Just Like Drinking Alcohol - Karnataka High Court

Introducing Age Limit For Use Of Social Media

This observation was made by a division bench of Justices G Narendar and Vijaykumar A Patil while hearing an appeal by X Corp (formerly Twitter).

It was challenging the single judge order of June 30 which had dismissed its plea to the takedown orders issued by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeiTY).

Under Section 69A of the Information Technology Act between February 2, 2021 and February 28, 2022, MeiTY had issued 10 Government Orders directing it to block 1,474 accounts, 175 Tweets, 256 URLs and one hashtag. 

In response to this, Twitter, now X corporation, challenged the orders related to 39 of these URLs. 

How Did This Happen?

Further, Justice G Narendar noted,”Ban social media. I will tell you a lot of good will come. Today’s school-going children are so addicted to it. I think there should be an age limit such as in the Excise rules.” 

“Children may be 17 or 18. But do they have the maturity to judge what is or is not in the interest of the nation? Not only on social media, but even on the Internet things should be removed, it corrupts the mind. The government should consider bringing in an age limit for the use of social media,” the court observed.

Besides this, the court had also imposed a cost of Rs 50 lakh on X Corp.

MeiTY had not informed the users about blocking their tweets and accounts and even the company was forbidden from informing them, X Corp’s counsel argued, in its defense.

Further, HC asked the Government saying, “You do not release the order. He is not permitted to reveal the order. How is he going to defend himself?” 

Moreover, the government may have to tweak the rules a bit as it is at the government’s discretion that X Corp is blocking the accounts of users and the company cannot be left high and dry, HC suggested.

Adding, “When it comes to national security, everybody has to be on the same page.” 

The bench said X Corp could not be the judge when the counsel for the company argued that it had informed which order of MeiTY it could comply with and which it could not.

The X Corp “cannot be given the right to judge the content. If the content says Apple a day keeps the doctor away, you will interpret that as being against the doctor and the interest of the nation?” the court said.

Moving ahead, the hearing of the case was adjourned to Wednesday when the HC will decide on the interim relief sought by X Corp and the hearing of the appeal will be heard after that, the HC said.


Sheetal Bhalerao
Sheetal Bhalerao
  • 796 Posts

Subscribe Now!

Get latest news and views related to startups, tech and business

You Might Also Like

Business
Dec. 8, 2022

Beat The Burden Of Medical Inflation With A Health Insurance

As disease rates rise and medical technology develops, treatment costs climb. It’s essential to understand that medical costs are not exclusively associated with hospitals. The cost of prescription drugs, diagnostic procedures, ambulance and operating room fees, consultations with doctors, and other costs are also constantly increasing. All of them could put a big strain on […]

Business
Dec. 8, 2022

3 Biggest Changes Of iOS 16.2 Update That Every iPhone User Should Know!

In its latest update Apple said that it is preparing for the iOS 16.2 update for iPhones across the world. Notably, like the previous release, there are a couple of changes coming for the iPhones.  iOS 16.2 Update Release Date So far, Apple has not announced a release date for iOS 16.2 update. Reportedly, the […]

Business
Dec. 8, 2022

300 Microsoft Employees Create Employee Union, First Time Ever: This Is How Microsoft Reacted

Around 300 workers at Microsoft Corp.’s ZeniMax Studios have commenced the process of forming a union which is said to be the first at the software giant in the US.  Here, Microsoft Corp.’s ZeniMax Studios known for popular video games including Skyrim and Fallout. Forming Union In Microsoft Corp Moreover, the quality assurance employees at […]

Business
Dec. 7, 2022

India Beats China In Air Travel Safety: Ranking Jumps From 102 To 48 In Global Aviation Safety

India’s air safety protocols and executions have improved drastically over the years, as validated by the findings of a specialized agency of the United Nations, the International Civil Aviation Organization or ICAO. The UN watchdog has upgraded India’s ranking in terms of aviation safety to the 48th position, jumping past the rankings of countries like […]

Recent Posts

Related Videos

   

Subscribe Now!

Get latest news and views related to startups, tech and business

who's online